• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

By the Way Bakery: Gluten-Free Custom Cakes and Bakeries in New York City

By the Way Bakery is a gluten-free bakery located in New York. They offer a variety of custom cakes, muffins, scones, and cookies, all made with high-quality ingredients. Their almond cookies are a crowd favorite, with a perfect balance of crunchiness and chewiness. Customers praise their accommodating service and delicious treats, especially for those with food allergies. While some find the cakes a bit too sweet, the variety of options, including vegan and dairy-free choices, make it a go-to spot for anyone with dietary restrictions. Overall, By the Way Bakery delivers tasty and satisfying desserts for all to enjoy.

By the Way Bakery at a glance

  • Address 2440 Broadway New York, NY 10024
  • Phone (212) 877-0806
  • Restaurant type Bakery .

Photos & Gallery

By the Way Bakery: Reviews & Ratings

Danielle
5

I am Celiac and I love the cakes here! Favorite is the lemon cake The chocolate truffle torte is what I imagine heaven to be like Also, Baxter’s Biscuits cured my pups tummy troubles- miracle!!! By the Way is my favorite gluten-free bakery

Al Cohen
5

Nice to get high end dairy and gluten free pastries to bring to friends without worry. Their kosher too. I'll say that prices do seem sky high even for Manhattan. $35 for a 7-8" pecan tort? But there was a line when I stopped in the day before Thanksgiving... All that said, everyone loved the tort!

IQ
5

Amazing bakery!!had a custom cake made for my daughter’s sweet 16th bday. All I sent them was a picture (not even a good one we found online) and not only did they make it exactly what my daughter wanted, but it was delicious! We were hesitant at first since we didn’t have good experiences with gluten free cake. This was the best moist and delicious gluten cake ever.

Suzie Carpenter
5

Amazing sweet treats from breakfast to dessert! Cakes are so moist and delicious - best tasting GFDF cake I’ve ever bought! Brownies also moist and dense, not crumbly or cakey. Very very good!

Amy McKinstry
5

I had no idea this place was GF and Dairy Free... Now it makes sense why the cream puff didn't have any cream lol. Instead of cream, it has a cookie dough like consistency in the middle, and it just works. As an avid sweet enthusiast, these were great! I will definitely stop by again.

Bryan Mirabella
5

By The Way Bakery – A True UWS Treasure By The Way Bakery is one of those hidden gems you could easily walk right past — but you definitely shouldn’t. Their crème puffs are hands down the best I’ve ever tasted: light, delicate, and absolutely unforgettable. And the pumpkin non-dairy cheesecake? Truly to die for. A must-visit spot on the Upper West Side. Everything here feels like a delicious little secret you’ll be grateful you discovered.

danny ochoa
5

Ordered a chocolate cake for my wife who has some dietary restrictions. It was some sort of chocolate cake, and let me tell you, it was amazing and delicious. Would absolutely recommend!

Brandie Webb
5

All I can say is how AMAZING these cakes are! I ordered a gluten-free cake for a friend’s birthday, and every single person at the party (15 people!) raved about it. Everyone kept saying how delicious it was and couldn’t believe how moist and flavorful a gluten-free cake could be. I will absolutely be buying all of my cakes here from now on!

Location

  • By the Way Bakery
    By the Way Bakery
    2440 Broadway New York, NY 10024 Hotline: (212) 877-0806

By the Way Bakery, located at 2440 Broadway in New York, is a haven for those with dietary restrictions. Specializing in custom cakes and baked goods, this bakery offers a range of options that cater to gluten-free and vegan diets. The menu includes a variety of treats from almond cookies with a crunchy exterior and chewy interior to indulgent brownies and classic chocolate chip cookies.

The bakery also excels in small treats like banana walnut muffins, blueberry corn muffins, and cinnamon chocolate chip muffins, all made with high-quality ingredients and bursting with flavor. Customers rave about the almond cookies and dairy-free birthday cakes, praising the bakery for its delicious offerings that cater to a variety of dietary needs.

One standout feature of By the Way Bakery is its commitment to quality and customer service. Reviews mention the accommodating staff who go above and beyond to fulfill special requests, such as early cake pickups and customized orders. Customers appreciate the bakery's attention to detail and dedication to providing delicious treats that everyone can enjoy.

If you're in the mood for a sweet treat that won't compromise your dietary restrictions, By the Way Bakery is the place to go. With a range of options for gluten-free, dairy-free, and vegan diets, this bakery offers something for everyone. Stop by for a taste of their delectable treats and experience the quality and care that go into each and every bite.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Service options
    • Offers delivery
    • In-store pick-up for online orders
    • Has in-store shopping
    • Offers takeaway
    • Offers same-day delivery
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments